Experts argue SEC cannot claim jurisdiction over Ethereum transactions

Must read

FTX looking to raise $1B in funding at $32B valuation

FTX looking to raise $1B in funding at $32B valuation Zeynep Geylan · 15 mins ago · 2 min read...

India considering GST on crypto transactions amid evaluation of sector’s legality

India considering GST on crypto transactions amid evaluation of sector’s legality Cynthia Chung · 1 hour ago · 2 min...

Zilliqa launches web3 gaming console with in-built miner and crypto wallet

Zilliqa launches web3 gaming console with in-built miner and crypto wallet Liam 'Akiba' Wright · 2 hours ago · 2...

Binance sets up global advisory board to drive responsible regulation of crypto

Binance sets up global advisory board to drive responsible regulation of crypto Christian Nwobodo · 2 hours ago · 2...

Experts argue SEC cannot claim jurisdiction over Ethereum transactions Experts argue SEC cannot claim jurisdiction over Ethereum transactions Oluwapelumi Adejumo · 3 hours ago · 2 min read

The SEC’s jurisdiction claim sets a dangerous precedence for the crypto industry as assets whose nodes are densely clustered in the US could face this overreach in the future.

2 min read

Updated: September 20, 2022 at 11:57 am

Experts argue SEC cannot claim jurisdiction over Ethereum transactions

Cover art/illustration via CryptoSlate

Xeggex

Several experts have disagreed with the U.S. SEC’s claim that it has jurisdiction over Ethereum transactions because there are more ETH nodes in the country than any other.

SEC claims jurisdiction over ETH transactions

In its charges against crypto promoter Ian Balina, the SEC said several U.S.-based investors participated in an investment pool that Ethereum network nodes validated.

The regulator argued that since these nodes “are clustered more densely in the United States than in any other country,” the transactions happened in the country.

The SEC’s jurisdiction claim sets a dangerous precedence for the crypto industry as assets whose nodes are densely clustered in the U.S. could face this overreach in the future.

According to Ethernodes data, roughly 43% of Ethereum validator nodes operate from the U.S., with Germany being the second with 12%.

With concerns about censorship currently in the air, U.S. regulators having jurisdiction over Ethereum itself could make it even easier to directly censor the network instead of just pressuring the validators.

Experts disagree with the SEC

Meanwhile, several crypto experts are questioning SEC’s jurisdiction claim over Ethereum.

An adjunct professor and partner at Cinneamhain Ventures, Adams Cochran, said the SEC had the perfect case but decided to use it to set a precedent and try to bring all cryptocurrencies under its jurisdiction.

Cochran said:

“This is an absolutely unacceptable overstep that will have to be pushed back against aggressively.”

Dylan LeClair of UTXO Management said the claim would have “very ugly implications” if it serves as a precedent.

Woah – quiet the bombshell statement from the SEC within a new suit against a 2018 ICO for selling unregistered securities.

Very ugly implications here if this is the precedent. pic.twitter.com/eYElw9BHno

— Dylan LeClair 🟠 (@DylanLeClair_) September 19, 2022

Other crypto community members also knocked the SEC for its overreach.

SEC vs. Ian Balina, released today, included the following noteworthy bit. Essentially: “ETH nodes are clustered more heavily in US than other places, therefore alleged crime on Ethereum network happened in US”

To be watched. pic.twitter.com/ZvjQ0yLrhf

— AlexanderGrieve.sol/.eth (@AlexanderGrieve) September 19, 2022

Previously, the SEC chair Gary Gensler said crypto assets that allow staking could qualify as securities under the Howey test. The statement was made hours after Ethereum (ETH) completed its migration to a proof-of-stake consensus mechanism.

More articles

Latest article

FTX looking to raise $1B in funding at $32B valuation

FTX looking to raise $1B in funding at $32B valuation Zeynep Geylan · 15 mins ago · 2 min read...

India considering GST on crypto transactions amid evaluation of sector’s legality

India considering GST on crypto transactions amid evaluation of sector’s legality Cynthia Chung · 1 hour ago · 2 min...

Zilliqa launches web3 gaming console with in-built miner and crypto wallet

Zilliqa launches web3 gaming console with in-built miner and crypto wallet Liam 'Akiba' Wright · 2 hours ago · 2...

Binance sets up global advisory board to drive responsible regulation of crypto

Binance sets up global advisory board to drive responsible regulation of crypto Christian Nwobodo · 2 hours ago · 2...

Helium community votes to migrate to Solana, scores new T-Mobile partnership

Helium community votes to migrate to Solana, scores new T-Mobile partnership Oluwapelumi Adejumo · 3 hours ago · 2 min...